An American stalwart gets help from his friends
Tony Bennett and Dave Brubeck – The White House Sessions, Live 1962 (Sony Legacy, 2013)
It seems straightforward. A jazz titan and lounge god perform a one-off set in the shadow of the Washington Monument at the behest of J.F.K. But a little background magnifies the music. Brubeck, a piano prodigy from California, and Bennett, the hard-luck son of Italian immigrants, served in the army during World War II. The former led a racially-integrated jazz band and never saw combat while the latter fought on the front lines of Europe near war’s end. Each came home an avowed pacifist and better citizen. Brubeck’s set best reflects such worldly views. “Castilian Blues” comes with a complex Latin beat that allows drummer Joe Morello room to improvise, and the Middle Eastern flair of “Nomad” features a resplendent turn from the always jovial saxophonist, Paul Desmond. After Brubeck’s four-song stay, Bennett gets his turn, performing 10 brisk numbers of which six feature Brubeck. Crooners are privy to overdoing ballads — mistaking bombast for brilliance — but a festive mood fitting of the occasion makes Bennett keep things upbeat. Highlights include the one wherein a new romance overcomes his bad bank account and the finale in which both performers push each other in a spirited display of their powers. The song is called, “There Will Never Be Another You.” How fitting. GRADE: A-
Key Tracks: “Nomad” / “Rags to Riches” / “There Will Never Be Another You”
Tony Bennett and Lady Gaga – Cheek to Cheek (Streamline/Interscope/Columbia, 2014)
As someone who hasn’t laughed at Family Guy in over a decade, know I appreciate swing jazz standards for their place in the American songbook and not much else. Give me garage-band grit over Broadway grace and hip-hop swagger over cocktail hour prissiness. But I nonetheless get the appeal. Bennett is 88 years old here, a one-man tower of song, a monument of charisma and a model of resiliency from The Greatest Generation. As for Gaga, a show tunes addict from a posh East Coast family, her arena-ready voice fits the mood and carries the weight of this collab’s half hour run time. The track list includes takes on Porter, Berlin, Gershwin and the whole thing sounds every bit the Grammy-bait it is. The production is crisp, the band is sharp and the harmonies are as well-lubricated as you’d expect. This is a real duets album, though. He keeps it cool, she keeps it ebullient. He plays it straight, she plays the ham. When each takes their respective solo turn, they become victims of their hubris and the genre’s sappiest, most regrettable tendencies. When they ditch the ballads and stick with the lounge bar pzazz, however, you understand why both live for this shit in the first place. GRADE: B+
Key Tracks: “Anything Goes” / “Cheek to Cheek” / “It Don’t Mean a Thing (If It Ain’t Got That Swing)”